List of fish by shadow size

This is a list of all the fish by shadow size.

Microscopic
The sizes of these shadows are smaller than your fishing bobber.
 * Angelfish
 * Bitterling
 * Clownfish
 * Goldfish
 * Guppy
 * Neon Tetra
 * Popeyed Goldfish
 * Sea Butterfly
 * Seahorse
 * Loach

Small
Small fish shadows are about the size of your bobber.
 * Bluegill
 * Butterflyfish
 * Crawfish
 * Crucian Carp
 * Frog
 * Freshwater Goby
 * Horse Mackerel
 * Jellyfish
 * Killifish
 * Loach
 * Pale Chub
 * Piranha
 * Pond Smelt
 * Surgeonfish

Small trash and other items

 * Can
 * Key
 * Tire
 * Medicine

Medium
These ones are slightly bigger than the small shadows.
 * Barbel Steed
 * Barred Knifejaw
 * Char
 * Cherry Salmon
 * Dab
 * Dace
 * Octopus
 * Puffer Fish
 * Red Snapper
 * Squid
 * Sweetfish
 * Yellow Perch
 * Zebra Turkeyfish

Medium trash

 * Boot

Large
These large shadows are about the size of your body.
 * Arowana
 * Black Bass
 * Carp
 * Catfish
 * Football fish
 * Koi
 * Olive Flounder
 * Rainbow Trout
 * Salmon

Large trash

 * Tire

Very Large
These fish shadows, implying the name, are very large. They are about the size of your entire character. Some people confuse the Sea Bass for something greater so that problem will be fixed if you read on.
 * Dorado
 * Giant Snakehead
 * Lobster
 * Moray Eel
 * Pike
 * Sea Bass

Long and thin
One of the most noticeable fish shadows, the eel is the only fish who has this shadow.
 * Eel

Huge
These are the largest fish shadows. They appear larger than very large, only less round and have a longer tail.

Don't mistake them for Sea Bass.
 * Arapaima
 * Blue Marlin
 * Coelacanth
 * Gar
 * King Salmon
 * Napoleonfish
 * Ray
 * Stringfish
 * Tuna
 * Giant Squid

Gigantic
Whale (Cannot be caught)

Huge (with fin)
Arguably the most noticeable, these fish shadows have a fin sticking out on top. They are also huge.
 * Hammerhead Shark
 * Ocean Sunfish
 * Shark